
Satay Inn Malaysian Restaurant
270 Victoria St, Melbourne
Ph +61 3 9329 0329.
Last night we took a trip up to Satay Inn (opposite the Vic Market) in Victoria St, for dinner.
From looking at their website, it looked like we would finally find some of the authentic Malaysian dishes we’d been searching for since we started this blog. Especially when I saw this claim - “…our cooking is done by a Malaysian chef who knows his craft well. Not a non-Malaysian who is doubtful about what the taste should be…”
Their website isn’t flash, but I hoped they put the real effort in where it counted - into the food. The pictures on the site had the feel of the kinds of dishes you’d be served at a Malaysian Mamak, so fingers crossed.
Curiously enough, Stay Inn also claims it is the oldest Malaysian restaurant in Melbourne - something we noted in our earlier review of Golden Orchids - we were hoping there were no more similarities.
Being a Friday, I rang mid-afternoon to book ourselves a table, just incase we turned up to a full house. The manager answered and I placed the booking, but I got the feeling he thought it was a strange request. Hmm.
When we arrived at 7.30pm, we entered to find one other couple dining. The rest of the seats were empty. Perhaps that was why the manager thought my booking request was strange? Anyway, we picked a table and sat down, and the waitress fetched us a menu and a glass of water each.

We decided to share an entree of Chicken Satay, and for mains Louis liked the sound of the Char Kway Teow, and I figured i’d try the Nasi Goreng - all very standard Malaysian dishes.
We looked around the interior while we were waiting for our meal to arrive, there were ‘Malaysia, Truly Asia’ mobiles hanging from the ceiling which would have been more at home in a travel agents’ office, and the walls had photocopies of various thank-you letters, newsclippings and random quotes. The lighting was also a bit dim (’mood’ lighting, again like Golden Orchids..)
A fairly short time later, the food arrived.

Chicken Satay - 5 Sticks ($7.50)
Say goodbye to the deep fried - we BBQ over charcoal fire

Char Kway Teow ($8.50)
Flat rice noodles wok tossed with egg, prawns and chicken

Nasi Goreng ($10.50)
Spicy Malay fried rice with rendang, egg, prawn, peas and diced carrot
Chicken Satay - I didn’t mind the taste of the satay sauce, but it wasn’t anything that I couldn’t replicate at home with a can of Ayam Satay Sauce. As for the satay sticks, I can’t really say much - as they didn’t really have much flavour (unless you covered them with the satay sauce). At least the chicken wasn’t dry I guess.
Char Kway Teow - Floury rice noodles, a few b-grade prawns, a few vegies, covered with a wholesome burnt taste throughout. I’ll give Louis 5 stars just for clearing his plate.
Nasi Goreng - My Nasi Goreng didn’t taste that great, but if you were coming from the Char Kway Teow it really did taste a lot better (comparatively). It had a certain level of spicyness (spices, not chilli hot), but was still so far off the mark it wasn’t funny. And the chunks of carrot were just.. strange.
Evidently the bits of meat through it were Rendang, so i’m especially glad I didn’t order a plate of Rendang Curry because there was little or no taste to that, either.
I’ll live in hope the next one we find will be decent.
The restaurant was dimly lit, with nary a customer in sight. The was only other table occupied, but fair enough, we will not judge a restaurant based on the amount of clients - it could have been a slow night. Not the best decor, but the walls had very Malaysian-themed posters and photos, and there was Malay music playing. The ambience was distinctively Malaysian, but can we say the same of the food?
I looked through the menu - a decent selection of mostly Chinese and Malay food. I decided on Char Kuay Teow, but decided to ask the waitress if they put cockles in their version. After all, what is a sinful dish of Char Kuay Teow without cockles to complete it? I was rather annoyed when the waitress just gave me a blank stare. I presume she was Malay, thus not familiar with how the authentic Chinese version is done. That should have been sufficient warning, but i decided to order anyway to see how far off the mark they could get. Here’s my verdict of everything i sampled:
Chicken Satay - Thick chunks of chicken, but unfortunately nothing like the tasty bite-sized skewer sticks so common on Malaysian roadside stalls. I would say its a problem with the marinade and cuts of meat. The satay sauce almost made it, but not quite. Besides, what kind of place calls itself Satay Inn, but serve tomatoes and cucumbers in place of ketupats (Malay rice dumplings)?
Char Kuay Teow - Dry, overladen with garlic and tasting a tad burnt, this was a far cry from the guilty pleasure of the Penang version. The noodles were stuck together, and flavor-wise i could only taste burnt bits of the wok and too much garlic. The more i ate, the more i looked forward to writing a scathing review (which you are reading). Honestly, the best comparison i can say to give you an idea is - know how lots of Malaysian stalls like to train their Indo/Filo maids to do Chinese cooking, ending up with sub-par versions just to cut costs? This tastes exactly like that.
Nasi Goreng - I had a taste of Damien’s dish as well - i think it couldn’t make up its mind whether it wanted to be Chinese fried rice or nasi goreng.
Add to your del.icio.us




you guys should try ampang yong tau fu at Doncaster East 13 Village Avenue. Try the assam laksa only serve on sat and sun it’s pretty good.
And try Laksa King at Shop 3, 320 Racecourse Rd, Flemington
Left by Sue on January 8th, 2008